The above is a screenshot from a post that was written on someone else’s blog. I was linked to the post on Twitter this morning by someone. Obviously you can tell I’m a little stirred up by what I read.
When I started The Spartan Warrior I made a vow to myself and everyone else out there that might come across my blog that this place would be a guiding light for the truth concerning nutrition and fitness. In my own way I am doing what I can to defend the rights of others to pursue the goal of a healthy lifestyle.
The desire to expose inaccuracies and to promote the truth comes from a lifetime spent in an unhealthy state supported by unhealthy practices in my own life. I spent the majority of it overweight and unhappy. Then as the years went on I spent my time spinning my wheels trying every new diet, product, pill or fitness program that became available. Once I started to thoroughly study the science behind nutrition and fitness everything suddenly became crystal clear.
Something that I deal with daily is a population of people that want to propegate information that is not entirely true. There are those that want to fearmonger food, claim their opinions concerning a diet as truth and push their own personal beliefs of what is healthy on to their readers. I just can’t let that happen. I can’t let the possibility of someone reading an opinion and believing it as truth without seeing the science and research behind both sides.
The following sections that are in block quotes are pulled from the article that the screenshot above was taken from. Directly after each quoted section are my responses in bold.
Everything in moderation? I don’t think so.
This link points to an article written on The Huffington Post. The post that it is linked to included no scientific research or studies and is purely based on opinion. A wrong one at that.
It is a common saying, but the philosophy of “Everything in moderation is OK” is, unfortunately, a myth.
The philosophy of “Everything in moderation is OK” is not a myth. This is an extreme example, but hopefully you get where I’m coming from. (http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/)
Weight loss is determined by calories in vs. calories out. (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357)
Should a recovering alcoholic have an occasional drink “in moderation”? Do you really think that is a good idea? Is it even possible, if someone had an addictive relationship with alcohol? Of course it isn’t. Is it ok for someone who is trying to quit smoking to have “cheat cigarettes” on the weekend? Do I even need to ask?
Hold on just one second. You’re going to say that alcoholism (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0001940/), a very real, abusive addiction that is something that to this day is vigorously debated as a disease is comparitive to eating a diet comprised of moderation?
Wait, are you kidding me? You’re going to say that smoking cigarettes, which is also an addiction to tobacco/nicotine, is even relatable to eating foods you enjoy in moderation on infrequent occurences? You do realize that smoking is the leading cause of lung cancer, can cause birth defects, respiratory and heart diseases.. right?
“Of the more than 2.4 million deaths in the USA annually, over 440,000 are caused by smoking.” (http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/10566.php)
Please show me how many deaths occur each year from someone eating processed foods in moderation such as grains, butter, poptarts, ice cream or anything else that they might enjoy.
You know your relationship with food. Have you ever experienced an addictive relationship? Have you ever binged on junk food? If the answer is “yes”, then you may need to avoid a “moderation” approach to crappy food. Eat all the healthy food you want. I know that it is possible to eat healthy food like a ravenous beast and not have a weight problem, if it truly is healthy food prepared intelligently AND you exercise regularly.
“Eat all the healthy food you want.” Thanks for clearing that up because I was unaware that if I ate 20,000 calories in surplus over my total daily energy expenditure that I would not gain any weight as long I “exercise regularly” and I intelligently prepare my food. You, sir, are some sort of wizard to be able to defy the laws of thermodynamics. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_of_thermodynamics)
I’m going to venture a guess that the majority of people that can’t stick to a diet is partially due to the diet’s restrictive parameters that create somewhat of a psychological break down regarding the relationship with food the dieter develops.
Some so-called “foods” simply don’t have enough of a “positive return” to even be worth eating. This is especially true when those foods mess up all of the hard progress you’ve made resetting your taste buds. I’ve experienced this firsthand. I eat Paleo. After a couple months of eating this way (e.g., no sugars or processed food), natural fruit and natural nut butters tasted like dessert to me. They seriously taste like a sweet candy. But, if I ever slip up and eat some crappy desserts, my taste buds get overwhelmed. For a few days, fruit no longer tastes sweet enough for me. Food no longer tastes salty enough. Those junk foods and cheat meals sabotage your progress. They mess with your perception of taste and “fullness”. It is a proven psychological and physiological phenomenon.
Apparently you’ve never eaten a pop-tart if you have no idea what a “positive return” from food is. Watch yourself in the mirror when you eat one. Pure elation.
No sugars? I wonder what’s in fruit. It couldn’t be fructose or any sort of sugar right?
“But, if I ever slip up and eat some crappy desserts, my taste buds get overwhelmed.” So, you slip up too and you don’t eat entirely paleo all the time. Do you know why? It might be because of what I said in the above paragraph about restrictive parameters. You are denying yourself something psychologically that you enjoy thus creating a very poor relationship with food that causes you to “cheat” or “binge” on foods you don’t normally eat at times.
Junk foods and cheat meals actually don’t sabotage your progress in any way. Overeating, negativity, self-hate.. those are some of the major things that sabotage progress. Also, when a diet is comprised of a majority of whole foods with those “processed” foods being consumed in moderation it’s easy to not cheat or binge because you don’t feel restricted in the diet. There’s not a need to because it’s no longer cheating, it’s part of living a healthy lifestyle both physically and mentally.
Also, on the topic of cheat meals, they can actually be beneficial to a diet if implemented correctly and if one is practicing more restriction in the diet than most people do on average. (http://www.livestrong.com/article/542505-the-art-and-science-of-cheat-meals/)
“They mess with your perception of taste and “fullness”. It is a proven psychological and physiological phenomenon.” Where is the science and research to back this up? Come on. Any person that’s ever eaten a meal in their life can tell you with ease that a plate of protein and starchy carbs will fill you up more than a plate of skittles. Here’s the thing though: No one that preaches a moderate diet is saying to eat that entire plate of skittles. What hey are saying is that if you have a few skittles it’s not going to hurt you or your progress and can benefit your psyche in the long run.
Take some advice from someone who has been there. I love food. I love desserts. Always have, even as a young child. But, I learned to reset my body to appreciate the natural sweetness and pleasure of real food like fruits, vegetables, etc. It is possible. And I learned that I simply need to avoid crappy processed food and cheat meals. Moderation doesn’t work for food that doesn’t deserve to be eaten in the first place.

I attempted to not make this reply out to be some sort of a personal attack on you in any way, but you’re throwing around your opinions with no research or studies to back it up. Hopefully this long-winded rebuttal isn’t taken as a personal attack.
Okay, I’m going to try and relate it to something else. Math. You can’t answer math equations based on your opinion of the answer. You actually have to formulate the correct answer through procedural calculation. However, if you backed up your opinion of what the answer is with a proven formula (research) and then show how it was done (studies) how could anyone discredit you? Unfortunately, you aren’t doing that.
Lastly, I just want to say that I think the big take away from the original post I’m responding to as well as what I have said here should be to focus on the individual’s personal relationship with food. Yes, some people may need to cut out all processed foods due to their unhealthy psychological relationship with food, but that is absolutely, 100% not the case for everyone out there.
Take some advice from someone who has been there. I love food. I love desserts. Always have, even as a young child. But, I learned to eat those things I love in moderation and have a diet that is comprised of a majority of whole foods. I don’t scapegoat any one macronutrient. I don’t restrict any specific foods. I don’t tell myself I can’t or I’m not able to. The only thing I watch out for is the quantity and the frequency in which I eat food. Not just processed foods, but all food.
It is possible to love yourself and your food, but it’s up to you to try.